BNC#6: Msimang Q&A – Leading with Ubuntu, education reform, SA needs integrity and accountability in government

During a Q&A session at BNC#6 in Hermanus, BizNews founder Alec Hogg and ANC veteran Mavuso Msimang engaged in a candid discussion covering historical parallels between Brazil and South Africa, education reform, affirmative action, political leadership, and Ubuntu philosophy. Msimang emphasised the need for improved education, accountability in governance, and ethical leadership. Their conversation explored strategies for societal progress amidst challenges, with a call for more effective engagement and reform within political structures.

Sign up for your early morning brew of the BizNews Insider to keep you up to speed with the content that matters. The newsletter will land in your inbox at 5:30am weekdays. Register here.

Watch here

Listen here

Summary of the Q&A session with ANC veteran Mavuso Msimang at BNC#6 in Hermanus

Alec Hogg and Mavuso Msimang delve into a multifaceted dialogue encompassing historical reflections, educational challenges, political leadership, and philosophical ideals. Drawing parallels between Brazil and South Africa, they discuss the complexities of merging diverse societies for mutual benefit. Msimang highlights the dire need for educational reform, citing issues such as inadequate early childhood education and the resultant hindrance to socio-economic advancement. He advocates for affirmative action while acknowledging its historical misapplications, emphasizing the imperative of inclusive strategies beyond government intervention.

The conversation extends to political dynamics, with scrutiny on the ANC’s governance and the quest for ethical leadership. Msimang critiques the party’s decline in policy quality and calls for electoral system reforms to enhance accountability and grassroots representation. Amidst challenges, including corruption allegations and political disillusionment, he stresses the importance of integrity and public engagement in shaping a more responsive governance framework.

Moreover, the discourse touches on the philosophical concept of ubuntu, which Msimang views as foundational to ethical behaviour and societal cohesion. However, he underscores the necessity of practical implementation over mere rhetoric, emphasizing the need for tangible actions aligned with ethical principles.

Throughout the dialogue, both Hogg and Msimang express optimism tempered by realism regarding South Africa’s future trajectory. While acknowledging the nation’s challenges, including educational disparities and governance deficiencies, they underscore the resilience of its democracy and the potential for positive change through concerted efforts and citizen engagement. Ultimately, the discussion serves as a call to action for more effective governance, inclusive policies, and a recommitment to ethical values in navigating South Africa’s path forward.

Edited transcript of the Q&A session with Mavuso Msimang at BNC#6 in Hermanus ___STEADY_PAYWALL___

Alec Hogg [00:00:07]

Thanks, Mavuso. It was interesting listening to your perspective on the merger between different societies in South Africa. Your insights are reminiscent of a historical analogy from Brazil. Before we dive deeper into your research, do you have any practical thoughts on merging societies like this?

Mavuso Msimang [00:01:35]

Essential to merging societies is improving education, a sector currently failing many. Private schooling becomes an escape for those who can afford it, exacerbating societal divides. We need to rally people to defend democracy and build a nation benefiting all, particularly by addressing educational disparities.

Alec Hogg [00:04:33]

Education reform is crucial. Take Thomas Edison, for instance, who succeeded with minimal formal education. We need to rethink our approach and unlock the potential of our diverse population.

Mavuso Msimang [00:05:24]

The challenge lies in convincing those in power to embrace innovative education methods. The current system’s shortcomings are evident, and civil society must push for change alongside government efforts.

Alec Hogg [00:08:33]

Shifting gears, let’s discuss leadership. With Cyril Ramaphosa’s resignation, what’s your stance on his political future?

Mavuso Msimang [00:08:54]

Ramaphosa’s role remains uncertain amidst ongoing political shifts. While I’m not advocating for my own path, I believe ethical leadership is paramount for progress.

Alec Hogg [00:10:36]

Should Ramaphosa step away from politics, given recent developments?

Mavuso Msimang [00:10:36]

My focus isn’t on personal decisions but rather on fostering moral authority within political spheres, regardless of individual leaders.

Alec Hogg [00:11:47]

What’s next for you?

Mavuso Msimang [00:11:47]

I’ve been working on a book, but the current climate keeps pulling me back into action, much like the historical figure Simon.

Alec Hogg [00:13:13]

Your family history reflects South Africa’s complex narrative.

Mavuso Msimang [00:13:13]

Indeed, my ancestors navigated challenging times, highlighting the intricate tapestry of our nation’s history.

Alec Hogg [00:14:44]

Looking ahead, could a government of national unity post-elections be viable?

Mavuso Msimang [00:14:44]

It’s a challenging proposition, given past experiences with coalition politics at lower levels of governance.

Alec Hogg [00:17:56]

Are you optimistic about South Africa’s future?

Mavuso Msimang [00:17:56]

Despite uncertainties, South Africa’s resilience gives me hope. Our democracy, though imperfect, lays the foundation for progress.

BizNews Community Member [00:19:55]

On a lighter note, someone mentioned your resemblance to Morgan Freeman. Any thoughts on that?

Mavuso Msimang [00:20:23]

While flattered, I’m grateful to not be compared to certain other figures.

BizNews Community Member [00:21:29]

How do we address educational inequality effectively?

Mavuso Msimang [00:21:40]

Improving literacy rates is paramount. We need coordinated efforts to push for innovative solutions and hold the government accountable for educational reform.

BizNews Community Member [00:25:15]

Can the ANC adopt a more positive outlook on governance?

Mavuso Msimang [00:25:15]

Electoral reforms could enhance accountability and bring leaders closer to their constituents, fostering a more positive approach to governance.

BizNews Community Member [00:30:58]

How can organizations overcome government barriers to early childhood education and entrepreneurship development?

Mavuso Msimang [00:30:58]

Collaboration and dialogue are key. While challenging, engaging with government officials and advocating for change is essential to address these barriers.

BizNews Community Member [00:32:36] I

s there merit in applying ubuntu principles to governance?

Mavuso Msimang [00:32:43]

Ethical leadership transcends philosophical labels. Regardless of terminology, leaders must prioritize integrity and accountability.

Alec Hogg [00:35:07]

Thank you, Mavuso, for sharing your insights with us today.