* . *
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact
Wednesday, August 6, 2025
Earth-News
  • Home
  • Business
  • Entertainment
    Rachael Leigh Cook and Brandon Routh ‘Happy to Have Found Each Other’ Following Respective Divorces – yahoo.com

    Rachael Leigh Cook and Brandon Routh ‘Happy to Have Found Each Other’ Following Respective Divorces – yahoo.com

    ‘Billie Jean’ – Hyde Park Herald

    The Enduring Magic Behind ‘Billie Jean’ Revealed

    Hank Hill returns to a changed world in new ‘King of the Hill’ episodes – New Haven Register

    Hank Hill Navigates a Bold New World in Thrilling New ‘King of the Hill’ Episodes

    Exclusive | Fox Takes Stake in IndyCar Owner Penske Entertainment – The Wall Street Journal

    Exclusive | Fox Takes Stake in IndyCar Owner Penske Entertainment – The Wall Street Journal

    Go-to entertainment: why gaming was made for the toilet – The Guardian

    Why Gaming Is the Ultimate Way to Pass Time in the Bathroom

    Chicago Youth Symphony Orchestra takes the Lollapalooza stage – Yahoo Home

    Chicago Youth Symphony Orchestra takes the Lollapalooza stage – Yahoo Home

  • General
  • Health
  • News

    Cracking the Code: Why China’s Economic Challenges Aren’t Shaking Markets, Unlike America’s” – Bloomberg

    Trump’s Narrow Window to Spread the Truth About Harris

    Trump’s Narrow Window to Spread the Truth About Harris

    Israel-Gaza war live updates: Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh assassinated in Iran, group says

    Israel-Gaza war live updates: Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh assassinated in Iran, group says

    PAP Boss to Niger Delta Youths, Stay Away from the Protest

    PAP Boss to Niger Delta Youths, Stay Away from the Protest

    Court Restricts Protests In Lagos To Freedom, Peace Park

    Court Restricts Protests In Lagos To Freedom, Peace Park

    Fans React to Jazz Jennings’ Inspiring Weight Loss Journey

    Fans React to Jazz Jennings’ Inspiring Weight Loss Journey

    Trending Tags

    • Trump Inauguration
    • United Stated
    • White House
    • Market Stories
    • Election Results
  • Science
  • Sports
  • Technology
    Future Trends In HR Technology – Dataconomy

    Future Trends In HR Technology – Dataconomy

    Nasdaq-listed Verb Technology to build $558 million TON treasury, rebrand as TON Strategy Co. – The Block

    Nasdaq-Listed Verb Technology to Build $558 Million TON Treasury and Rebrand as TON Strategy Co

    How Tech Firms Like Google and Meta Are Embracing the Military – The New York Times

    How Tech Firms Like Google and Meta Are Embracing the Military – The New York Times

    Credo Technology: Wiring The AI Revolution (NASDAQ:CRDO) – Seeking Alpha

    Credo Technology: Driving the Next Wave of AI Innovation

    Microsoft Seeks to Extend Access to OpenAI Technology – PYMNTS.com

    Microsoft Aims to Broaden Access to OpenAI Technology

    Livonia police use grappler technology to stop drunk driver – ClickOnDetroit | WDIV Local 4

    Livonia Police Deploy Grappler Technology to Safely Stop Drunk Driver

    Trending Tags

    • Nintendo Switch
    • CES 2017
    • Playstation 4 Pro
    • Mark Zuckerberg
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Business
  • Entertainment
    Rachael Leigh Cook and Brandon Routh ‘Happy to Have Found Each Other’ Following Respective Divorces – yahoo.com

    Rachael Leigh Cook and Brandon Routh ‘Happy to Have Found Each Other’ Following Respective Divorces – yahoo.com

    ‘Billie Jean’ – Hyde Park Herald

    The Enduring Magic Behind ‘Billie Jean’ Revealed

    Hank Hill returns to a changed world in new ‘King of the Hill’ episodes – New Haven Register

    Hank Hill Navigates a Bold New World in Thrilling New ‘King of the Hill’ Episodes

    Exclusive | Fox Takes Stake in IndyCar Owner Penske Entertainment – The Wall Street Journal

    Exclusive | Fox Takes Stake in IndyCar Owner Penske Entertainment – The Wall Street Journal

    Go-to entertainment: why gaming was made for the toilet – The Guardian

    Why Gaming Is the Ultimate Way to Pass Time in the Bathroom

    Chicago Youth Symphony Orchestra takes the Lollapalooza stage – Yahoo Home

    Chicago Youth Symphony Orchestra takes the Lollapalooza stage – Yahoo Home

  • General
  • Health
  • News

    Cracking the Code: Why China’s Economic Challenges Aren’t Shaking Markets, Unlike America’s” – Bloomberg

    Trump’s Narrow Window to Spread the Truth About Harris

    Trump’s Narrow Window to Spread the Truth About Harris

    Israel-Gaza war live updates: Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh assassinated in Iran, group says

    Israel-Gaza war live updates: Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh assassinated in Iran, group says

    PAP Boss to Niger Delta Youths, Stay Away from the Protest

    PAP Boss to Niger Delta Youths, Stay Away from the Protest

    Court Restricts Protests In Lagos To Freedom, Peace Park

    Court Restricts Protests In Lagos To Freedom, Peace Park

    Fans React to Jazz Jennings’ Inspiring Weight Loss Journey

    Fans React to Jazz Jennings’ Inspiring Weight Loss Journey

    Trending Tags

    • Trump Inauguration
    • United Stated
    • White House
    • Market Stories
    • Election Results
  • Science
  • Sports
  • Technology
    Future Trends In HR Technology – Dataconomy

    Future Trends In HR Technology – Dataconomy

    Nasdaq-listed Verb Technology to build $558 million TON treasury, rebrand as TON Strategy Co. – The Block

    Nasdaq-Listed Verb Technology to Build $558 Million TON Treasury and Rebrand as TON Strategy Co

    How Tech Firms Like Google and Meta Are Embracing the Military – The New York Times

    How Tech Firms Like Google and Meta Are Embracing the Military – The New York Times

    Credo Technology: Wiring The AI Revolution (NASDAQ:CRDO) – Seeking Alpha

    Credo Technology: Driving the Next Wave of AI Innovation

    Microsoft Seeks to Extend Access to OpenAI Technology – PYMNTS.com

    Microsoft Aims to Broaden Access to OpenAI Technology

    Livonia police use grappler technology to stop drunk driver – ClickOnDetroit | WDIV Local 4

    Livonia Police Deploy Grappler Technology to Safely Stop Drunk Driver

    Trending Tags

    • Nintendo Switch
    • CES 2017
    • Playstation 4 Pro
    • Mark Zuckerberg
No Result
View All Result
Earth-News
No Result
View All Result
Home Business

High court rules ‘certificates of need’ unconstitutional, again: Ivo Vegter

July 27, 2024
in Business
High court rules ‘certificates of need’ unconstitutional, again: Ivo Vegter
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

The North Gauteng High Court has reaffirmed that the Health Act’s “Certificates of Need” (CONs) are unconstitutional, drawing a definitive line against central planning in private healthcare. This ruling, echoing a 2022 decision, invalidates the requirement for government-issued permits to establish or modify health facilities, citing violations of Constitutional rights and inefficiency. The judgment challenges government overreach and sets a precedent for limiting licensing practices across industries.

Sign up for your early morning brew of the BizNews Insider to keep you up to speed with the content that matters. The newsletter will land in your inbox at 5:30am weekdays. Register here.

Join us for BizNews’ first investment-focused conference on Thursday, 12 September, in Hermanus, featuring top experts like Frans Cronje, Piet Viljoen, and more. Get insights on electricity and exploiting SA’s gas bounty from new and familiar faces. Register here.

By Ivo Vegter*

High Court ruling reconfirms that the Health Act’s “Certificates of Need” are unconstitutional and draws a line in the sand.

Stop me if you’ve heard this one before: the North Gauteng High Court has declared that Certificates of Need, as contemplated in sections 36 to 40 of the National Health Act, are unconstitutional.

You’ll have heard it before, because it happened before. These clauses were struck down in a 2022 ruling, but that judgment was rescinded in 2023 because the Health Minister didn’t to turn up to court, thanks to a snafu in legally serving papers by the sheriff of the court.

Section 36 of the National Health Act says that nobody may establish, construct, modify or acquire a health establishment or health agency; increase the number of beds in, or acquire prescribed health technology at, a health establishment or health agency; provide prescribed health services; or continue to operate a health establishment or health agency…without being in possession of a certificate of need.

Essentially, it tells private doctors and healthcare facilities that they may operate only if, and where, government decides they are needed. The requirement had not yet entered into force.

Central-planning madness

The decision on whether there is sufficient need for a given health service in a given location was to be made by the director-general of the Department of Health.

For each certificate of need, the DG had to consider a multitude of factors. These include “the need to ensure consistency of health services development in terms of national, provincial and municipal planning; the need to promote an equitable distribution and rationalisation of health services and health care resources, and the need to correct inequities based on racial, gender, economic and geographical factors; the need to promote an appropriate mix of public and private health services; the demographics and epidemiological characteristics of the population to be served; the potential advantages and disadvantages for existing public and private health services and for any affected communities; the need to protect or advance persons or categories of persons designated in terms of the Employment Equity Act, 1998 (Act No. 55 of 1998), within the emerging small, medium and micro-enterprise sector; the potential benefits of research and development with respect to the improvement of health service delivery; the need to ensure that ownership of facilities does not create perverse incentives for health service providers and health workers; if applicable, the quality of health services rendered by the applicant in the past; the probability of the financial sustainability of the health establishment or health agency; the need to ensure the availability and appropriate utilisation of human resources and health technology; whether the private health establishment is for profit or not…”

You get the idea. It’s central-planning madness.

“Invalid in their entirety”

In a comprehensively reasoned judgment, a different judge reached the same conclusion as did the judge in the 2022 matter: requiring a Certificate of Need for the provision of private healthcare services violates several Constitutional rights, is irrational, is procedurally unfair, and that, consequently, sections 36 (and 37 to 40 which depend upon it) are invalid in their entirety and are severed from the Act.

The respondents – the Minister of Health, the President of the Republic of South Africa, and the Director-General of the National Department of Health – were ordered to pay the costs of the applicants, who include the Solidarity Trade Union, the Alliance of South African Independent Practitioner Associations, the South African Private Practitioner Forum, the Hospital Association of South Africa, and several individuals.

It is ridiculous that this case took not one, but two court cases to resolve. It is heartening that the addition of a response by the government did not materially change the opinion of the court.

The judge held that requiring a permission slip from the government to provide private healthcare services in a particular location, or even just to expand and improve existing private facilities, is a violation of the Constitutional rights to dignity, to freedom of movement and residence, to freely choose a trade, occupation or profession, not to be arbitrarily deprived of property, and also infringes the right of access to healthcare for the general public.

Cornerstone demolished

The Democratic Alliance’s spokesperson on health, Michele Clarke, said in a statement: “The ruling has important implications for the implementation of the National Health Insurance (NHI) Act as the Act heavily relies on CONs for the placement of service providers, like doctors or nurses, in specific communities.”

This is true, and Solidarity rightly presented this judgment as having demolished a cornerstone of the NHI, which bodes well for the broader legal campaign to have the NHI Act declared invalid.

“In essence, these sections would have empowered the government to capture medical practices almost entirely and to manage them at will – rather than them being run at the discretion of the doctors. We cannot simply hope that the government would simply always apply its wide discretions responsibly. A government should not have such powers at all,” explained Dirk Hermann, the CEO of Solidarity.

Price mechanism versus central planning

When the previous judgment was rescinded last year, I explained why the government is in principle not in a position to determine “need”. The information needed to evaluate the multitude of factors the law would have required the Health DG to take into account is widely dispersed among private individuals acting according to their subjective value judgements.

In particular, “the probability of the financial sustainability of the health establishment or health agency” cannot reliably be predicted by an outside agency.

Such information can be aggregated by markets through the price mechanism, but it is simply not available to would-be central planners. For this reason, government planning will always be less efficient than the spontaneous market-based organisation of productive resources.

Wider precedent

This judgement sets a wider precedent, however. It strictly limits the extent to which the government can intervene to “plan” private sector production. It clearly declares that private property and private resources are not available to the government to harness in the pursuit of its own planning and objectives.

That will – or it should, at least – ripple through a multitude of industries where the freedom to trade is limited by the requirement to obtain a licence from the government.

Not all licence conditions are irrational, or violate Constitutional rights, but many do. All manner of licence conditions could be challenged on the basis of this precedent, using very similar arguments to those the applicants made in this case.

The practice of limiting the number of licences available for certain kinds of industry or commerce could also be challenged on the same basis.

This judgment should be welcomed as having drawn a line in the sand that tells the socialist planners in government: this far, and no further.

That line should be vigorously defended, if the private sector is to reinvigorate the economy and return the country to robust economic growth.

Read also:

NHI will lead to healthcare collapse, drive doctors abroad: Woode-Smith
How disruption is shaping the future of healthcare and its impact on medical real estate
Healthcare sector celebrates its release from Certificate of Need red tape

*Ivo Vegter is a freelance journalist, columnist and speaker 

This article was first published by Daily Friend and is republished with permission

>>> Read full article>>>
Copyright for syndicated content belongs to the linked Source : BizNews – https://www.biznews.com/rational-perspective/2024/07/26/certificates-need-unconstitutional-ivo-vegter

Tags: businesscourtRules
Previous Post

South Africa’s Apple price war: Asbis vs. Core Group

Next Post

Why SA “irritates” “most” African countries…

Edward McNabb, pioneer of conservation bioacoustics and nocturnal ecology, died on May 7th, aged 81 – Butler Nature

Remembering Edward McNabb: Trailblazer in Conservation Bioacoustics and Nocturnal Ecology Passes Away at 81

August 5, 2025
Insider’s View: Europe can be a leader in AI for science – Science|Business

Insider’s View: Europe can be a leader in AI for science – Science|Business

August 5, 2025
The FDA is targeting orange juice. Here’s why, and what the science says. – The Boston Globe

Why the FDA Is Targeting Orange Juice-and What the Science Actually Reveals

August 5, 2025
Beyond Nutritional Deficiencies: Managing GLP-1 Side Effects With Lifestyle Interventions – Patient Care Online

Beyond Nutritional Deficiencies: Managing GLP-1 Side Effects With Lifestyle Interventions – Patient Care Online

August 5, 2025
Shaw Travels To China For World Games With U.S. Men’s National Team – hailstate.com

Shaw Joins U.S. Men’s National Team for Thrilling World Games Showdown in China

August 5, 2025

A Turbulent Week Rocks the American Economy

August 5, 2025
Rachael Leigh Cook and Brandon Routh ‘Happy to Have Found Each Other’ Following Respective Divorces – yahoo.com

Rachael Leigh Cook and Brandon Routh ‘Happy to Have Found Each Other’ Following Respective Divorces – yahoo.com

August 5, 2025
Chatbots Can Trigger a Mental Health Crisis. What to Know About ‘AI Psychosis’ – Time Magazine

When Chatbots Spark a Mental Health Crisis: Unraveling the Enigma of ‘AI Psychosis

August 5, 2025

Why Young Adults Are Checking Out of Politics and Choosing Not to Vote

August 5, 2025
Future Trends In HR Technology – Dataconomy

Future Trends In HR Technology – Dataconomy

August 5, 2025

Categories

Archives

August 2025
MTWTFSS
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031
« Jul    
Earth-News.info

The Earth News is an independent English-language daily published Website from all around the World News

Browse by Category

  • Business (20,132)
  • Ecology (756)
  • Economy (781)
  • Entertainment (21,658)
  • General (16,306)
  • Health (9,818)
  • Lifestyle (789)
  • News (22,149)
  • People (780)
  • Politics (790)
  • Science (15,994)
  • Sports (21,276)
  • Technology (15,758)
  • World (762)

Recent News

Edward McNabb, pioneer of conservation bioacoustics and nocturnal ecology, died on May 7th, aged 81 – Butler Nature

Remembering Edward McNabb: Trailblazer in Conservation Bioacoustics and Nocturnal Ecology Passes Away at 81

August 5, 2025
Insider’s View: Europe can be a leader in AI for science – Science|Business

Insider’s View: Europe can be a leader in AI for science – Science|Business

August 5, 2025
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact

© 2023 earth-news.info

No Result
View All Result

© 2023 earth-news.info

No Result
View All Result

© 2023 earth-news.info

Go to mobile version