* . *
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact
Saturday, September 27, 2025
Earth-News
  • Home
  • Business
  • Entertainment
    Cardi B Adds More Dates to Little Miss Drama Tour: ‘Y’all Making Me Work’ – Yahoo

    Cardi B Extends Little Miss Drama Tour: “Y’all Making Me Work

    ‘Today’: Sheinelle Jones Thanks Katie Couric for Support After Husband’s Death – CBS 19 News

    Sheinelle Jones Expresses Heartfelt Thanks to Katie Couric for Support After Husband’s Passing

    Sate your hunger at DBA’s Taste of Downtown – Bakersfield.com

    Indulge Your Cravings at DBA’s Taste of Downtown!

    Caesars Entertainment (CZR): Assessing Valuation After Times Square Casino Setback and Mounting Investor Concerns – simplywall.st

    Caesars Entertainment Faces Times Square Casino Hurdles as Investor Concerns Mount

    Why Hilaria Baldwin Has Found the ‘DWTS’ Process ‘Embarrassing’ At Times – WFXG

    Hilaria Baldwin Opens Up About the Embarrassing Moments on Her ‘DWTS’ Journey

    Harvest Fest 2025 – yadkinripple.com

    Celebrate the Bounty: Harvest Fest 2025 is Coming!

  • General
  • Health
  • News

    Cracking the Code: Why China’s Economic Challenges Aren’t Shaking Markets, Unlike America’s” – Bloomberg

    Trump’s Narrow Window to Spread the Truth About Harris

    Trump’s Narrow Window to Spread the Truth About Harris

    Israel-Gaza war live updates: Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh assassinated in Iran, group says

    Israel-Gaza war live updates: Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh assassinated in Iran, group says

    PAP Boss to Niger Delta Youths, Stay Away from the Protest

    PAP Boss to Niger Delta Youths, Stay Away from the Protest

    Court Restricts Protests In Lagos To Freedom, Peace Park

    Court Restricts Protests In Lagos To Freedom, Peace Park

    Fans React to Jazz Jennings’ Inspiring Weight Loss Journey

    Fans React to Jazz Jennings’ Inspiring Weight Loss Journey

    Trending Tags

    • Trump Inauguration
    • United Stated
    • White House
    • Market Stories
    • Election Results
  • Science
  • Sports
  • Technology
    Aurora police hope to add facial recognition technology to crime-fighting tools – CBS News

    Aurora Police Aim to Boost Crime-Fighting with New Facial Recognition Technology

    Autonomous Solutions shows off cutting-edge technology for the public – Cache Valley Daily

    Autonomous Solutions Unveils Cutting-Edge Technology for the Public

    Amazon to Pay $2.5 Billion in Prime Membership Settlement – The New York Times

    Amazon to Pay $2.5 Billion in Prime Membership Settlement – The New York Times

    What are we really gaining from technology? – Fast Company

    What Are We Really Gaining from Technology?

    TOMI Environmental Solutions, Inc. Expands SteraMist iHP Technology Services in Healthcare Sector with New Provider Partnership – Quiver Quantitative

    TOMI Environmental Solutions Accelerates SteraMist iHP Technology Expansion in Healthcare with New Provider Partnership

    Indiana County Technology Center’s Joint Operating Committee looks to the future as program plans began to take shape – Indiana Gazette Online

    Indiana County Technology Center’s Joint Operating Committee Charts an Exciting Path Forward as New Program Plans Take Shape

    Trending Tags

    • Nintendo Switch
    • CES 2017
    • Playstation 4 Pro
    • Mark Zuckerberg
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Business
  • Entertainment
    Cardi B Adds More Dates to Little Miss Drama Tour: ‘Y’all Making Me Work’ – Yahoo

    Cardi B Extends Little Miss Drama Tour: “Y’all Making Me Work

    ‘Today’: Sheinelle Jones Thanks Katie Couric for Support After Husband’s Death – CBS 19 News

    Sheinelle Jones Expresses Heartfelt Thanks to Katie Couric for Support After Husband’s Passing

    Sate your hunger at DBA’s Taste of Downtown – Bakersfield.com

    Indulge Your Cravings at DBA’s Taste of Downtown!

    Caesars Entertainment (CZR): Assessing Valuation After Times Square Casino Setback and Mounting Investor Concerns – simplywall.st

    Caesars Entertainment Faces Times Square Casino Hurdles as Investor Concerns Mount

    Why Hilaria Baldwin Has Found the ‘DWTS’ Process ‘Embarrassing’ At Times – WFXG

    Hilaria Baldwin Opens Up About the Embarrassing Moments on Her ‘DWTS’ Journey

    Harvest Fest 2025 – yadkinripple.com

    Celebrate the Bounty: Harvest Fest 2025 is Coming!

  • General
  • Health
  • News

    Cracking the Code: Why China’s Economic Challenges Aren’t Shaking Markets, Unlike America’s” – Bloomberg

    Trump’s Narrow Window to Spread the Truth About Harris

    Trump’s Narrow Window to Spread the Truth About Harris

    Israel-Gaza war live updates: Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh assassinated in Iran, group says

    Israel-Gaza war live updates: Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh assassinated in Iran, group says

    PAP Boss to Niger Delta Youths, Stay Away from the Protest

    PAP Boss to Niger Delta Youths, Stay Away from the Protest

    Court Restricts Protests In Lagos To Freedom, Peace Park

    Court Restricts Protests In Lagos To Freedom, Peace Park

    Fans React to Jazz Jennings’ Inspiring Weight Loss Journey

    Fans React to Jazz Jennings’ Inspiring Weight Loss Journey

    Trending Tags

    • Trump Inauguration
    • United Stated
    • White House
    • Market Stories
    • Election Results
  • Science
  • Sports
  • Technology
    Aurora police hope to add facial recognition technology to crime-fighting tools – CBS News

    Aurora Police Aim to Boost Crime-Fighting with New Facial Recognition Technology

    Autonomous Solutions shows off cutting-edge technology for the public – Cache Valley Daily

    Autonomous Solutions Unveils Cutting-Edge Technology for the Public

    Amazon to Pay $2.5 Billion in Prime Membership Settlement – The New York Times

    Amazon to Pay $2.5 Billion in Prime Membership Settlement – The New York Times

    What are we really gaining from technology? – Fast Company

    What Are We Really Gaining from Technology?

    TOMI Environmental Solutions, Inc. Expands SteraMist iHP Technology Services in Healthcare Sector with New Provider Partnership – Quiver Quantitative

    TOMI Environmental Solutions Accelerates SteraMist iHP Technology Expansion in Healthcare with New Provider Partnership

    Indiana County Technology Center’s Joint Operating Committee looks to the future as program plans began to take shape – Indiana Gazette Online

    Indiana County Technology Center’s Joint Operating Committee Charts an Exciting Path Forward as New Program Plans Take Shape

    Trending Tags

    • Nintendo Switch
    • CES 2017
    • Playstation 4 Pro
    • Mark Zuckerberg
No Result
View All Result
Earth-News
No Result
View All Result
Home Business

Legal challenge to MK MP Hlophe’s JSC appointment …

July 10, 2024
in Business
Legal challenge to MK MP Hlophe’s JSC appointment …
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

There has been outrage in some circles over the National Assembly’s decision to designate as members of the Judicial Service Commission and Magistrates Commission, MPs “who have previously been found guilty of misconduct or have been criticised by courts for ethical breaches, such as Dr John Hlophe and Ms Faith Muthambi”. In this interview with BizNews, Mbekezeli Benjamin of Judges Matter says: “So for us, it is ironic and it is really inappropriate for the people who are scrutinising lawyers to be judges and magistrates are themselves unethical or have been found to have been unethical. Parliament as a body was supposed to be careful and thoughtful in who it puts forward, especially when there are findings by the Judicial Service Commission that said that Dr. Hlophe was guilty of gross misconduct, which is the worst form of misconduct that a person holding judicial office can be found guilty of. They completely ignored those findings and they said he’s suitable to sit on the JSC. So that is the argument that has been made and that case is being filed by the Freedom Under Law NGO.”

Sign up for your early morning brew of the BizNews Insider to keep you up to speed with the content that matters. The newsletter will land in your inbox at 5:30am weekdays. Register here.

Join us for BizNews’ first investment-focused conference on Thursday, 12 September, in Hermanus, featuring top experts like Frans Cronje, Piet Viljoen, and more. Get insights on electricity and exploiting SA’s gas bounty from new and familiar faces. Register here.

Watch here

Listen here

Highlights from the interview

In a recent interview, Chris Steyn discussed the controversy surrounding the appointments to the Judicial Service Commission (JSC) and the Magistrates Commission with Mbekezeli Benjamin from Judges Matter. Benjamin highlighted the problematic designations of former Minister Faith Muthambi and Dr. John Hlophe to these commissions. He argued that their appointments undermine the commissions’ mandate to ensure only ethically sound and fit individuals are appointed as judicial officers, as per Section 174 of the Constitution.

Benjamin emphasized that the JSC, comprising 23 members, must uphold high ethical standards, scrutinizing candidates rigorously. He pointed out the irony and inappropriateness of having individuals with questionable ethics themselves in positions meant to judge the suitability of others. Benjamin criticized Parliament’s decision-making process, stressing that it should ensure the independence and dignity of the courts as mandated by Section 165 of the Constitution.

Judges Matter and other organizations had previously written to Parliament to object to these appointments, but their concerns were dismissed. Benjamin mentioned that Freedom Under Law plans to challenge the decision in court, citing rationality and rule of law principles, referencing a similar case involving Menzi Simelane.

Regarding the designation of Julius Malema of the Economic Freedom Fighters to the JSC, Benjamin noted that while initially controversial, Malema has recently contributed positively, asking pertinent questions about ethics and the application of the Constitution. Benjamin concluded by emphasizing the importance of the JSC’s unique structure and the need for appropriate and qualified members.

Edited transcript of the interview ___STEADY_PAYWALL___

Chris Steyn (00:03.24)

There is outrage in some circles about the designations of certain people to the Judicial Service Commission and the Magistrates Commission. We speak to Mr. Mbekezeli Benjamin of Judges Matter. Good morning, Mr. Benjamin.

Mbekezeli Benjamin (00:18.926)

Good morning, good morning Chris and thank you so much for having us.

Chris Steyn (00:23.464)

Which of those designations do you find problematic?

Mbekezeli Benjamin (00:28.078)

Well, we find problematic the designation of former Minister Faith Muthambi as part of the Magistrates Commission and Dr. John Hlophe as part of the Judicial Service Commission. We believe that both individuals are not suitable to be part of these commissions, particularly if you look at the role that both commissions play in terms of appointing judges and magistrates to our court.  And the key role and function that they play is that that they should check whether the judge or the magistrate or the judicial officer is fit and proper to be appointed as a judicial officer. 

There is a constitutional requirement in terms of Section 174 of the Constitution. It says only suitably qualified and fit and proper people. And what the JSC has said is fit and proper, is someone who is ethical, is someone who has integrity, someone who has not been previously been found guilty of any ethical indiscretion. 

So there shouldn’t be a disciplinary process, even a criminal process that has found that person guilty. So that is what is required of a judicial officer. 

And the people who do the job are the 23 members of the JSC. They sit as a collective to scrutinize – and scrutinize quite seriously – the candidates. And one of the things that the JSC has recently changed is that now, even if you have a judgment that against you, a debt against you, you should disclose it because that is something that goes to your integrity and that is something that they question. So even if you were involved in disciplinary proceedings and you were not even found guilty, but the mere fact that you were involved, both the Judicial Service Commission and the Magistrates Commission do question you on those things. So it is quite clear that for you to be scrutinized by the JSC there is a high ethical standard that is set for you.

Mbekezeli Benjamin (02:27.95)

So for us, it is ironic and it is really inappropriate for the people who are scrutinizing lawyers to be judges and magistrates are themselves unethical or have been found to have been unethical. That is the concern for us and which is why we believe that Parliament as a body should have been careful in taking the decision on who becomes a member of these commissions. 

There is a requirement in terms of the Constitution for Parliament as an institution to be 100% certain that it is protecting and upholding the tradition. Section 165 of the Constitution says that Parliament and any other organ of State should take measures to ensure the independence, the effectiveness and the dignity of the courts. And so for us, that requirement was not followed when Parliament decided to designate these individuals as part of the JSC and the Magistrates Commission.

Chris Steyn (03:27.592)

Now your NGO and five others in fact wrote to Parliament to object to the possibility of Dr. Hlophe being designated. That has now happened. What can you do now?

Mbekezeli Benjamin (03:41.902)

So yes, Judges Matter and six other organisations, we did write to the Speaker to raise the concerns about Parliament’s decision to designate certain individuals. The Speaker wrote back and said, look, there are measures in terms of the Oath of Office and the rules of Parliament that require members of Parliament to uphold certain ethical standards. 

And then she ultimately said she will leave it to the National Assembly as a body to take the decision.  So ultimately it was the National Assembly as a body that took the decision. And for us, that is the concern, right? Because a party can nominate someone, a party that was elected to the National Assembly can nominate anyone to be part of the JSC. But it is the Parliament as a body, Parliament as a collective, that is supposed to take the final decision. 

And when we look at the previous Parliament, the sixth Parliament, the Zondo Commission was very damning to say, you as Parliament failed in your responsibility to uphold accountability, to ensure that democratic institutions are functioning properly. You failed in that responsibility. So our expectation was that Parliament in the seventh Parliament, they would have learned some lessons from the Zondo Commission, they would have learned some lessons from the past and they would be very careful in who they put in these democratic institutions so that those institutions are strong, are credible, are effective in their responsibility. So it was quite disappointing to see Parliament vote to put these people forward. 

Now what should be done at this moment? There is already work, the Freedom Under Law has already indicated that they are taking the decision to court. They will be challenging the decision on the grounds of rationality and the rule of law that is encapsulated in Section One of the Constitution.

Mbekezeli Benjamin (05:41.664)

Now that rationality argument goes around the lines that were similarly made in the case involving Menzi Simelane. You’ll remember that former president Zuma appointed Menzi Simelane as the Head of the National Prosecuting Authority, and at the time the Ginwala Commission had found Menzi Simelane to not have been credible as a witness in those proceedings. And so what the Constitutional Court said is that it was irrational for former president Zuma to appoint Mr. Simelane to be the head of the NPA and completely ignore the findings of the Ginwala Commission who say that he was not credible as a witness. 

So on that same principle, it applies in this situation where Parliament as a body was supposed to be careful and thoughtful in who it puts forward, especially when there is findings by the Judicial Service Commission that said that Dr. Hlophe was guilty of gross misconduct, which is the worst form of misconduct that a person holding judicial office can be found guilty of. They completely ignored those findings and they said he’s suitable to sit on the JSC. So that is the argument that has been made and that case is being filed by the Freedom Under Law NGO.

Chris Steyn (09:18.952)

Now, may I ask you about some other designations? What do you make of the designation of Economic Freedom Fighters Commander-in-Chief, Mr. Julius Malema on the JSC?

Mbekezeli Benjamin (09:30.446)

So yes, firstly, I think we need to understand the role of the members of Parliament on the JSC and the Magistrates Commission. Let’s start with the JSC. The JSC is made up of 23 members. 13 of those members are lawyers and judges. There’s a law academic. And so the majority of the people on the JSC are legally trained people. So the 10 members of Parliament do not necessarily need to be legally trained. They don’t need to be lawyers themselves. Because their role on the JSC is to raise the concerns of the ordinary people who use the courts during the process of the JSC. So the role of their participation in the JSC is really to serve as public representatives. 

And in fact, the current Speaker, Ms Thokozile Didiza , when she was a member of the JSC, she played that role effectively. She’s not a lawyer, but she was very good at asking questions of ethics, of asking questions about gender and the functioning of the court and how they interpret the law in consideration of gender factors. So she played that role well because she understood the role of the Member of Parliament as a public representative on the JSC. 

So similarly, we are not judging Dr. Hlophe on his legal qualifications. Of course, he has a PhD from Cambridge, which is a very high and esteemed qualification, but there is more to it that is required when you are a Member of Parliament. You should be able to ask questions of ethics. 

So Mr. Malema, initially, there was some uproar around his appointment, but initially, in fact, over the last 10 years he served on the JSC, there have been concerns about his behaviour on the JSC, where he used that platform to try and advocate for what are issues that are not really related to someone’s suitability to be a judge. It was more to do with party politics. 

Mbekezeli Benjamin (11:33.984)

But over the last two years, he has changed. He has been much more effective as a commissioner. He’s raised very difficult questions about people’s ethics, ironically. He has questioned candidates on their ethical standards, on their understanding of substantive equality in terms of the Constitution, their understanding of transformation. And one of the interesting things that he raised recently was that transformation is not just about numbers, it’s about the substantive understanding of the Constitution and how someone will apply the Constitution if they are appointed as a judge. And so Mr. Malema has made quite a shift as a member of the JSC. He’s been quite effective and has added some value in how the JSC functions. 

And so the role of a Member of Parliament is important. We believe the JSC as an institution is unique. It is the only body in the whole of the South African State that includes the representation from the judiciary, from the legislature, and from the executive sitting in one room and deciding on an important issue like the appointment of judges. So we do would want that uniqueness to be kept, but we want the right people to be doing the job.

Chris Steyn (12:54.28)

Thank you. That was Mr. Mbekezeli Benjamin of Judges Matters, speaking to BizNews. And I am Chris Steyn. Thank you, Sir.

Read also:

Magnus Heystek: Why I am investing in South Africa again
Ten pitfalls that SA’s GNU needs to avoid: Flip Buys
Time to bring back the rainbow nation: Ivo Vegter

>>> Read full article>>>
Copyright for syndicated content belongs to the linked Source : BizNews – https://www.biznews.com/interviews/2024/07/10/mk-mp-hlophes-jsc-appointment

Tags: businessChallengeLegal
Previous Post

SA’s GNU must harness moderation and goodwill for growth: Terence Corrigan

Next Post

Climate change’s growing threat to South Africa’s tourism industry

What happens when President Trump attends major sports events – and why he does it – The Athletic – The New York Times

What happens when President Trump attends major sports events – and why he does it – The Athletic – The New York Times

September 27, 2025
New Delhi 2025: Preview, stars and how to watch the World Championships – Paralympic.org

New Delhi 2025 World Championships: Top Athletes to Watch and How You Can Catch the Action

September 27, 2025
Stock market exodus to Wall Street hits 20-year high – EL PAÍS English

Stock market exodus to Wall Street hits 20-year high – EL PAÍS English

September 27, 2025
October Prime Day TV Deals: Elevate Your Entertainment Space With These Early Savings – CNET

October Prime Day TV Deals: Upgrade Your Entertainment Space with These Early Savings

September 27, 2025
Georgia’s Medicaid work requirement program spent twice as much on administrative costs as on health care, GAO says – North Carolina Health News

Georgia’s Medicaid Work Requirement Program Spent Twice as Much on Administration as on Patient Care, GAO Finds

September 27, 2025
TGIF: Ian Donnis’ Rhode Island politics roundup for Sept. 26, 2025 – The Public’s Radio

TGIF: Ian Donnis’ Rhode Island politics roundup for Sept. 26, 2025 – The Public’s Radio

September 27, 2025
City Parks Initiative Launches Ecological Tracker for Bond Projects – Citizen Portal AI

Revolutionary Ecological Tracker Unveiled to Transform Monitoring of City Parks Bond Projects

September 27, 2025
Award-winning science writer leads student discussions at Eckerd – theonlinecurrent.com

Award-Winning Science Writer Inspires Student Discussions at Eckerd College

September 27, 2025
Human Head Transplants: Where the Science Stands, and Why the Ethics Are So Complicated – Discover Magazine

Human Head Transplants: The Science Behind the Procedure and the Complex Ethical Debate

September 27, 2025
New lifestyle brand TENŌRE set to open flagship store in Waikīkī – KITV

New lifestyle brand TENŌRE set to open flagship store in Waikīkī – KITV

September 27, 2025

Categories

Archives

September 2025
M T W T F S S
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
2930  
« Aug    
Earth-News.info

The Earth News is an independent English-language daily published Website from all around the World News

Browse by Category

  • Business (20,132)
  • Ecology (839)
  • Economy (860)
  • Entertainment (21,734)
  • General (17,271)
  • Health (9,903)
  • Lifestyle (872)
  • News (22,149)
  • People (861)
  • Politics (870)
  • Science (16,069)
  • Sports (21,360)
  • Technology (15,842)
  • World (842)

Recent News

What happens when President Trump attends major sports events – and why he does it – The Athletic – The New York Times

What happens when President Trump attends major sports events – and why he does it – The Athletic – The New York Times

September 27, 2025
New Delhi 2025: Preview, stars and how to watch the World Championships – Paralympic.org

New Delhi 2025 World Championships: Top Athletes to Watch and How You Can Catch the Action

September 27, 2025
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact

© 2023 earth-news.info

No Result
View All Result

© 2023 earth-news.info

No Result
View All Result

© 2023 earth-news.info

Go to mobile version