Eamon Ryan criticised for seeking Ireland's intervention in Swiss women's climate case

CLIMATE MINISTER EAMON Ryan has been criticised for seeking Ireland’s intervention in a court case taken by a group of older Swiss women over climate change.

The association of women – KlimaSeniorinnen Schweiz – took a case in the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) arguing that the Swiss government had not taken enough action on climate change and that this violated their health rights.

The court ruled that the Swiss government violated an article of the European Convention of Human Rights by not taking sufficient action to reduce emissions or making a clear plan for future reductions.

During the proceedings, the Irish government made an intervention and sent a legal team to Strasbourg to try to argue that the Convention does not guarantee the right to a healthy environment.

But the Court ultimately found the Convention entitles people to be protected by State authorities against adverse effects of climate change on their lives and health.

In response to a Parliamentary Question posed by Social Democrats TD Jennifer Whitmore about why Ireland had sought to intervene in the case as a third party, Ryan confirmed that he himself had sought and was granted the approval.

The Green Party leader said the Government is reviewing the ECHR ruling in consultation with the Attorney General’s office.

“In advance of this review occurring fully, it is not possible to determine what, if any, impact the ruling could have on the policy of the Government,” Ryan said.

“While the Government shares the environmental concerns of the applicants, the global climate crisis cannot best be addressed by litigation, but instead requires collaborative global efforts – efforts to which this Government is strongly committed.”

He said the Government was represented at the hearing by a senior and a junior counsel, and by officials from the Office of the Attorney General and the Department of Foreign Affairs. Written and oral observations were made on behalf of the State during the case.

“The final costs of these proceedings have not been determined and to date no payments have been made by my department,” he added.

In a statement today, Whitmore said Ryan’s decision to intervene in the Swiss case “is completely at odds with his own Climate Action Plan and could have undermined efforts to hold governments to account for failures in meeting targets”.

“As it has become blatantly obvious that this Government will miss its climate action targets, I can only assume it was the minister’s aim to prevent any possible cases being taken directly against the State,” she said.

People Before Profit TD Bríd Smith said she was “shocked” to learn that it was Ryan who instigated Ireland’s intervention in the Swiss case.

“When these women won their case ten days ago I applauded their civic spirit and bravery, but little did I know that it was Eamon Ryan who was leading the legal campaign against them,” Smyth said.

“I can think of nothing that illustrates the vacuous green washing politics of Eamon Ryan and the Green Party more than this. He should be ashamed of himself and he owes an apology to the women who brought and won this case.”

With reporting from Press Association

A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.

Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.

For the price of one cup of coffee each week you can make sure we can keep reliable, meaningful news open to everyone regardless of their ability to pay.