* . *
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact
Saturday, June 7, 2025
Earth-News
  • Home
  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • General
  • Health
  • News

    Trending Tags

    • Trump Inauguration
    • United Stated
    • White House
    • Market Stories
    • Election Results
  • Science
  • Sports
  • Technology

    Unlocking the Future: ECS Professor Pankaj K. Jha Secures NSF Grant for Groundbreaking Quantum Technology Development

    Revving Up Safety: 5 Innovative Upgrades for Fire Apparatus Technology

    U.S. FDA Grants Platform Technology Designation to the Viral Vector Used in SRP-9003, Sarepta’s Investigational Gene Therapy for the Treatment of Limb Girdle Muscular Dystrophy Type 2E/R4 – Sarepta Therapeutics

    Breakthrough for Gene Therapy: FDA Designates Viral Vector in Sarepta’s SRP-9003 for Limb Girdle Muscular Dystrophy Treatment

    Waunakee Fifth-Graders Dive into the Future at Exciting Tech Day!

    Property Technology Magazine Unveils “PropTech Top 50 Index” and the “2025 PropTech Trends Report – The Great Rebuild.” – Business Wire

    UBS Analyst Predicts Surge in Micron Technology Stock Price!

    Trending Tags

    • Nintendo Switch
    • CES 2017
    • Playstation 4 Pro
    • Mark Zuckerberg
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • General
  • Health
  • News

    Trending Tags

    • Trump Inauguration
    • United Stated
    • White House
    • Market Stories
    • Election Results
  • Science
  • Sports
  • Technology

    Unlocking the Future: ECS Professor Pankaj K. Jha Secures NSF Grant for Groundbreaking Quantum Technology Development

    Revving Up Safety: 5 Innovative Upgrades for Fire Apparatus Technology

    U.S. FDA Grants Platform Technology Designation to the Viral Vector Used in SRP-9003, Sarepta’s Investigational Gene Therapy for the Treatment of Limb Girdle Muscular Dystrophy Type 2E/R4 – Sarepta Therapeutics

    Breakthrough for Gene Therapy: FDA Designates Viral Vector in Sarepta’s SRP-9003 for Limb Girdle Muscular Dystrophy Treatment

    Waunakee Fifth-Graders Dive into the Future at Exciting Tech Day!

    Property Technology Magazine Unveils “PropTech Top 50 Index” and the “2025 PropTech Trends Report – The Great Rebuild.” – Business Wire

    UBS Analyst Predicts Surge in Micron Technology Stock Price!

    Trending Tags

    • Nintendo Switch
    • CES 2017
    • Playstation 4 Pro
    • Mark Zuckerberg
No Result
View All Result
Earth-News
No Result
View All Result
Home Technology

AI meets materials science: the promise and pitfalls of automated discovery

December 5, 2023
in Technology
AI meets materials science: the promise and pitfalls of automated discovery
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

December 4, 2023 3:18 PM

Artist's conception of an illustrated X-ray crystallographic image.

Credit: VentureBeat made with Midjourney

Are you ready to bring more awareness to your brand? Consider becoming a sponsor for The AI Impact Tour. Learn more about the opportunities here.

Last week, a team of researchers from the University of California, Berkeley published a highly anticipated paper in the journal Nature describing an “autonomous laboratory” or “A-Lab” that aimed to use artificial intelligence (AI) and robotics to accelerate the discovery and synthesis of new materials. 

Dubbed a “self-driving lab,” the A-Lab presented an ambitious vision of what an AI-powered system could achieve in scientific research when equipped with the latest techniques in computational modeling, machine learning (ML), automation and natural language processing.

Diagram showing how the A-Lab works: UC Berkeley/Nature

However, within days of publication, doubts began to emerge about some of the key claims and results presented in the paper. 

Robert Palgrave is an inorganic chemistry and materials science professor at University College London. He has decades of experience in X-ray crystallography. Palgrave raised a series of technical concerns on X (formerly Twitter) about inconsistencies he noticed in the data and analysis provided as evidence for the A-Lab’s purported successes. 

VB Event

The AI Impact Tour

Connect with the enterprise AI community at VentureBeat’s AI Impact Tour coming to a city near you!

Learn More

In particular, Palgrave argued that the phase identification of synthesized materials conducted by the A-Lab’s AI via powder X-ray diffraction (XRD) appeared to be seriously flawed in several cases and that some of the newly synthesized materials were already discovered.

AI’s promising attempts — and their pitfalls

Palgrave’s concerns, which he aired in an interview with VentureBeat and a pointed letter to Nature, revolve around the AI’s interpretation of XRD data – a technique akin to taking a molecular fingerprint of a material to understand its structure.

Imagine XRD as a high-tech camera that can snap pictures of atoms in a material. When X-rays hit the atoms, they scatter, creating patterns that scientists can read, like using shadows on a wall to determine a source object’s shape. 

Similar to how children use hand shadows to copy the shapes of animals, scientists make models of materials and then see if those models produce similar X-ray patterns to the ones they measured. 

Palgrave pointed out that the AI’s models didn’t match the actual patterns, suggesting the AI might have gotten a bit too creative with its interpretations.

Palgrave argued this represented such a fundamental failure to meet basic standards of evidence for identifying new materials that the paper’s central thesis — that 41 novel synthetic inorganic solids had been produced — could not be upheld. 

In a letter to Nature, Palgrave detailed a slew of examples where the data simply did not support the conclusions drawn. In some cases, the calculated models provided to match XRD measurements differed so dramatically from the actual patterns that “serious doubts exist over the central claim of this paper, that new materials were produced.” 

Although he remains a proponent of AI use in the sciences, Palgrave questions whether such an undertaking could realistically be performed fully autonomously with current technology. “Some level of human verification is still needed,” he contends.

Palgrave didn’t mince words: “The models that they make are in some cases completely different to the data, not even a little bit close, like utterly, completely different.” His message? The AI’s autonomous efforts might have missed the mark, and a human touch could have steered it right.

The human touch in AI’s ascent

Responding to the wave of skepticism, Gerbrand Ceder, the head of the Ceder Group at Berkeley, stepped into the fray with a LinkedIn post. 

Ceder acknowledged the gaps, saying, “We appreciate his feedback on the data we shared and aim to address [Palgrave’s] specific concerns in this response.” Ceder admitted that while A-Lab laid the groundwork, it still needed the discerning eye of human scientists.

Ceder’s update included new evidence that supported the AI’s success in creating compounds with the right ingredients. However, he conceded, “a human can perform a higher-quality [XRD] refinement on these samples,” recognizing the AI’s current limitations. 

Ceder also reaffirmed that the paper’s objective was to “demonstrate what an autonomous laboratory can achieve” — not claim perfection. And upon review, more comprehensive analysis methods were still needed.

The conversation spilled back over to social media, with Palgrave and Princeton Professor Leslie Schoop weighing in on the Ceder Group’s response. Their back-and-forth highlighted a key takeaway: AI is a promising tool for material science’s future, but it’s not ready to go solo.

Palgrave and his team plan to do a re-analysis of the XRD results, intending to produce a much more thorough description of what compounds were actually synthesized.

Navigating the AI-human partnership in science

For those in executive and corporate leadership roles, this experiment is a case study in the potential and limitations of AI in scientific research. It illustrates the importance of marrying AI’s speed with the meticulous oversight of human experts.

The key lessons are clear: AI can revolutionize research by handling the heavy lifting, but it can’t yet replicate the nuanced judgment of seasoned scientists. The experiment also underscores the value of peer review and transparency in research, as expert critiques from Palgrave and Schoop have highlighted areas for improvement.

Looking ahead, the future involves a synergistic blend of AI and human intelligence. Despite its flaws, the Ceder group’s experiment has sparked an essential conversation about AI’s role in advancing science. It’s a reminder that while technology can push boundaries, it’s the wisdom of human experience that ensures we’re moving in the right direction.
This experiment stands as both a testament to AI’s potential in material science and a cautionary tale. It’s a rallying cry for researchers and tech innovators to refine AI tools, ensuring they’re reliable partners in the quest for knowledge. The future of AI in science is indeed luminous, but it will shine its brightest when guided by the hands of those who have a deep understanding of the world’s complexities.

VentureBeat’s mission is to be a digital town square for technical decision-makers to gain knowledge about transformative enterprise technology and transact. Discover our Briefings.

>>> Read full article>>>
Copyright for syndicated content belongs to the linked Source : VentureBeat – https://venturebeat.com/ai/ai-meets-materials-science-the-promise-and-pitfalls-of-automated-discovery/

Tags: materialsmeetstechnology
Previous Post

New, open-source AI vision model emerges to take on ChatGPT — but it has issues

Next Post

Grand Theft Auto VI is set in Vice City, releases in 2025

Thresholds of functional trait diversity driven by land use intensification – Nature

Thresholds of functional trait diversity driven by land use intensification – Nature

June 7, 2025
Discovery Camps launch at the Museum of Science and History this summer – 104.5 WOKV

Exciting Discovery Camps Unveiled at the Museum of Science and History This Summer!

June 7, 2025

University of Texas Track Star Unleashes Imagination with New Science-Fiction Novel!

June 7, 2025
From Paris to Global: Yseult — Euromaxx – DW

Yseult: A Journey from Paris to Global Stardom

June 7, 2025
Norway vs. Italy: Livestream World Cup 2026 Qualifier Soccer From Anywhere – CNET

Norway vs. Italy: Livestream World Cup 2026 Qualifier Soccer From Anywhere – CNET

June 7, 2025
Dollar stores are seeing higher-income shoppers rush in the door. It’s a warning sign for the US economy. – Yahoo Finance

Why Higher-Income Shoppers Are Flocking to Dollar Stores: A Red Flag for the US Economy

June 7, 2025
Brass Lion Entertainment unveils co-op action RPG Wu-Tang: Rise of the Deceiver – VentureBeat

Unleash Your Inner Warrior: Discover the Co-Op Action RPG Wu-Tang: Rise of the Deceiver!

June 7, 2025
Popular Upper West Side restaurant Jacob’s Pickles shut down by NYC health department – ABC7 New York

Beloved Upper West Side Eatery Jacob’s Pickles Closes Its Doors After Health Department Intervention

June 7, 2025
Trump preparing large-scale cancellation of federal funding for California, sources say – CNN

Trump preparing large-scale cancellation of federal funding for California, sources say – CNN

June 7, 2025

Unlocking the Future: ECS Professor Pankaj K. Jha Secures NSF Grant for Groundbreaking Quantum Technology Development

June 7, 2025

Categories

Archives

June 2025
MTWTFSS
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30 
« May    
Earth-News.info

The Earth News is an independent English-language daily published Website from all around the World News

Browse by Category

  • Business (20,132)
  • Ecology (674)
  • Economy (688)
  • Entertainment (21,594)
  • General (15,268)
  • Health (9,729)
  • Lifestyle (691)
  • News (22,149)
  • People (688)
  • Politics (695)
  • Science (15,906)
  • Sports (21,191)
  • Technology (15,673)
  • World (673)

Recent News

Thresholds of functional trait diversity driven by land use intensification – Nature

Thresholds of functional trait diversity driven by land use intensification – Nature

June 7, 2025
Discovery Camps launch at the Museum of Science and History this summer – 104.5 WOKV

Exciting Discovery Camps Unveiled at the Museum of Science and History This Summer!

June 7, 2025
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact

© 2023 earth-news.info

No Result
View All Result

© 2023 earth-news.info

No Result
View All Result

© 2023 earth-news.info

Go to mobile version