* . *
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact
Friday, May 23, 2025
Earth-News
  • Home
  • Business
  • Entertainment
    Embracer intends to spin off Coffee Stain Group by the end of 2025, with remaining business rebranded as Fellowship Entertainment – GamesIndustry.biz

    Embracer intends to spin off Coffee Stain Group by the end of 2025, with remaining business rebranded as Fellowship Entertainment – GamesIndustry.biz

    San Jose eyes creation of entertainments zones with FIFA World Cup, Super Bowl LX on the horizon – The Mercury News

    San Jose Sets Its Sights on Exciting Entertainment Zones Ahead of FIFA World Cup and Super Bowl LX!

    Wilmington’s future of fun: 5 recreation and entertainment spaces planned in the Port City – Wilmington Star-News

    Exciting Developments Ahead: 5 New Recreation and Entertainment Spaces Coming to Wilmington!

    Jason Momoa Is Done With Peace in Apple’s ‘Chief of War’ Teaser – Yahoo

    Jason Momoa Embraces Chaos in Gripping Teaser for Apple’s ‘Chief of War’

    AI Entertainment Studio Promise Inks Deal With Google, Raises Investment from Michael Ovitz’s Crossbeam – The Hollywood Reporter

    AI Entertainment Studio Promise Secures Major Deal with Google and Attracts Investment from Michael Ovitz’s Crossbeam!

    Jennifer Lawrence and Robert Pattinson Did This “Humiliating” Thing to Prep for Sex Scenes – Yahoo

    Jennifer Lawrence and Robert Pattinson’s Hilarious Preparation for Steamy Sex Scenes!

  • General
  • Health
  • News

    Cracking the Code: Why China’s Economic Challenges Aren’t Shaking Markets, Unlike America’s” – Bloomberg

    Trump’s Narrow Window to Spread the Truth About Harris

    Trump’s Narrow Window to Spread the Truth About Harris

    Israel-Gaza war live updates: Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh assassinated in Iran, group says

    Israel-Gaza war live updates: Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh assassinated in Iran, group says

    PAP Boss to Niger Delta Youths, Stay Away from the Protest

    PAP Boss to Niger Delta Youths, Stay Away from the Protest

    Court Restricts Protests In Lagos To Freedom, Peace Park

    Court Restricts Protests In Lagos To Freedom, Peace Park

    Fans React to Jazz Jennings’ Inspiring Weight Loss Journey

    Fans React to Jazz Jennings’ Inspiring Weight Loss Journey

    Trending Tags

    • Trump Inauguration
    • United Stated
    • White House
    • Market Stories
    • Election Results
  • Science
  • Sports
  • Technology
    Aera Technology Debuts Decision Intelligence Skill to Navigate Shifting Tariff Dynamics Across Value Chains – Silicon Canals

    Unlocking Success: Aera Technology Launches Innovative Decision Intelligence Skill to Tackle Evolving Tariff Challenges in Value Chains

    Auditory Processing and Psychosocial Improvements with Remote Microphone Technology: An Evidence Review – The Hearing Review

    Unlocking Sound: How Remote Microphone Technology Enhances Auditory Processing and Boosts Psychosocial Well-Being

    Quadient and Nuvei Forge Strategic Technology Partnership – Finovate

    Quadient and Nuvei Forge Strategic Technology Partnership – Finovate

    Novotech Honored with Triple Win in 2025 Pharmaceutical Technology Excellence Awards – Morningstar

    Novotech Celebrates Triple Triumph at the 2025 Pharmaceutical Technology Excellence Awards!

    Experts Issue Warning on New TSA Technology – Men’s Journal

    Experts Sound Alarm Over New TSA Technology: What You Need to Know

    Cellino’s iPSC Manufacturing Technology Receives FDA Advanced Manufacturing Technology (AMT) Designation – Business Wire

    Cellino’s Groundbreaking iPSC Manufacturing Technology Earns FDA’s Advanced Manufacturing Designation!

    Trending Tags

    • Nintendo Switch
    • CES 2017
    • Playstation 4 Pro
    • Mark Zuckerberg
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Business
  • Entertainment
    Embracer intends to spin off Coffee Stain Group by the end of 2025, with remaining business rebranded as Fellowship Entertainment – GamesIndustry.biz

    Embracer intends to spin off Coffee Stain Group by the end of 2025, with remaining business rebranded as Fellowship Entertainment – GamesIndustry.biz

    San Jose eyes creation of entertainments zones with FIFA World Cup, Super Bowl LX on the horizon – The Mercury News

    San Jose Sets Its Sights on Exciting Entertainment Zones Ahead of FIFA World Cup and Super Bowl LX!

    Wilmington’s future of fun: 5 recreation and entertainment spaces planned in the Port City – Wilmington Star-News

    Exciting Developments Ahead: 5 New Recreation and Entertainment Spaces Coming to Wilmington!

    Jason Momoa Is Done With Peace in Apple’s ‘Chief of War’ Teaser – Yahoo

    Jason Momoa Embraces Chaos in Gripping Teaser for Apple’s ‘Chief of War’

    AI Entertainment Studio Promise Inks Deal With Google, Raises Investment from Michael Ovitz’s Crossbeam – The Hollywood Reporter

    AI Entertainment Studio Promise Secures Major Deal with Google and Attracts Investment from Michael Ovitz’s Crossbeam!

    Jennifer Lawrence and Robert Pattinson Did This “Humiliating” Thing to Prep for Sex Scenes – Yahoo

    Jennifer Lawrence and Robert Pattinson’s Hilarious Preparation for Steamy Sex Scenes!

  • General
  • Health
  • News

    Cracking the Code: Why China’s Economic Challenges Aren’t Shaking Markets, Unlike America’s” – Bloomberg

    Trump’s Narrow Window to Spread the Truth About Harris

    Trump’s Narrow Window to Spread the Truth About Harris

    Israel-Gaza war live updates: Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh assassinated in Iran, group says

    Israel-Gaza war live updates: Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh assassinated in Iran, group says

    PAP Boss to Niger Delta Youths, Stay Away from the Protest

    PAP Boss to Niger Delta Youths, Stay Away from the Protest

    Court Restricts Protests In Lagos To Freedom, Peace Park

    Court Restricts Protests In Lagos To Freedom, Peace Park

    Fans React to Jazz Jennings’ Inspiring Weight Loss Journey

    Fans React to Jazz Jennings’ Inspiring Weight Loss Journey

    Trending Tags

    • Trump Inauguration
    • United Stated
    • White House
    • Market Stories
    • Election Results
  • Science
  • Sports
  • Technology
    Aera Technology Debuts Decision Intelligence Skill to Navigate Shifting Tariff Dynamics Across Value Chains – Silicon Canals

    Unlocking Success: Aera Technology Launches Innovative Decision Intelligence Skill to Tackle Evolving Tariff Challenges in Value Chains

    Auditory Processing and Psychosocial Improvements with Remote Microphone Technology: An Evidence Review – The Hearing Review

    Unlocking Sound: How Remote Microphone Technology Enhances Auditory Processing and Boosts Psychosocial Well-Being

    Quadient and Nuvei Forge Strategic Technology Partnership – Finovate

    Quadient and Nuvei Forge Strategic Technology Partnership – Finovate

    Novotech Honored with Triple Win in 2025 Pharmaceutical Technology Excellence Awards – Morningstar

    Novotech Celebrates Triple Triumph at the 2025 Pharmaceutical Technology Excellence Awards!

    Experts Issue Warning on New TSA Technology – Men’s Journal

    Experts Sound Alarm Over New TSA Technology: What You Need to Know

    Cellino’s iPSC Manufacturing Technology Receives FDA Advanced Manufacturing Technology (AMT) Designation – Business Wire

    Cellino’s Groundbreaking iPSC Manufacturing Technology Earns FDA’s Advanced Manufacturing Designation!

    Trending Tags

    • Nintendo Switch
    • CES 2017
    • Playstation 4 Pro
    • Mark Zuckerberg
No Result
View All Result
Earth-News
No Result
View All Result
Home Technology

Court finds EncroChat hacked messages admissible as former footballer is jailed

March 23, 2024
in Technology
Court finds EncroChat hacked messages admissible as former footballer is jailed
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

A former Liverpool youth footballer has been jailed for supplying drugs after a judge ruled that messages and data harvested by police from the EncroChat encrypted phone network can be lawfully used as evidence in the case.

The case, known as Embossed II, was the “lead case” in a long-running legal argument over whether evidence obtained by French police from the EncroChat encrypted phone network is legally admissible in the UK courts. Jamie Cassidy, 46, was jailed for 13 years and three months for taking part in a large drugs conspiracy, after his activities were exposed by messages intercepted from the EncroChat encrypted phone network.

He was sentenced with his brother Jonathan Cassidy, 50, from Crosby in Merseyside, and Nasar Ahmed, 51, from Bury, at Manchester Crown Court on 21 March, over their involvement in a large international drugs operation. They pleaded guilty after Judge Nicholas Dean, the recorder of Manchester, found that messages obtained from the EncroChat encrypted phone network could be lawfully used as evidence in the case.

Dean also cleared the National Crime Agency and Crown prosecutors of “abuse of process” and dismissed arguments from defence lawyers that the agency had deliberately failed to disclose technical evidence needed by expert witnesses hired by the defendants.

The three men were arrested in 2020 after French police hacked into the EncroChat encrypted phone network and passed on messages to the National Crime Agency, which led to their identification as participants in an operation to import and distribute cocaine in the UK. It was part of a wider operation that led to French police obtaining 115 million messages from an estimated 60,000 users of EncroChat phones worldwide.

Police forces and law enforcement agencies in the UK have made more than 3,100 arrests, convicted 1,500 offenders, recovered over nine tonnes of Class A drugs, and seized 3,500 rounds of ammunition and £84m in cash, according to figures from Greater Manchester Police.

In a written ruling on 18 March that can now be reported, Judge Dean said there was no doubt that a vast amount of data was retrieved, and that the material, if admissible, implicates those proved to have used the handsets to send and receive messages in serious crime. “Whatever else, this is not a case of flawed or corrupted software giving the appearance of individuals being involved in criminal activity,” he said.

Storage vs transmission

The case is the latest to address the question of whether EncroChat evidence can be lawfully used as evidence in courts.

Under UK law, phone calls or data intercepted during the course of transmission are prohibited from being used as evidence, and cannot be referred to during a court hearing to protect the methods used by intelligence agencies and law enforcement.  

The restriction, however, does not apply if the same data is obtained from storage in an electronic device through a hacking – also known as equipment interference – operation.

The French have refused to disclose how the infiltration operation against EncroChat was carried out, citing defence secrecy. 

Prosecutors argued that French police infected EncroChat phones with a software implant that obtained the supposedly secure encrypted messages from electronic storage in phone handsets, and were therefore admissible under UK law.

Lawyers representing the defendants, however, argued there was evidence that EncroChat messages were intercepted during the course of transmission, and instructed expert witnesses to reverse-engineer EncroChat phones to discover how the interception process worked.

The defence arguments were dismissed by Dean in a ruling dated 18 March that found EncroChat messages were intercepted at a time they were “stored in or by the (telecommunications system)”, rather than during the course of transmission.

He said the issue had been litigated at least twice, including during two preparatory hearings that were scrutinised by the Court of Appeal.

Brief storage is still storage

According to submissions made by the French government to the European Court of Human Rights in April 2020, the French police used a “special investigative technique” to bypass EncroChat encryption that was capable of recording key strokes, capturing screen shots, and accessing and collecting data contained in a “digital terminal”.

The judge said an analogy used in the French submission, which compared the hacking operation to a search of a building containing illegal items such as drugs or fire arms, is consistent only with the French government regarding all the data as having been collected from storage in handsets.

The French implant collected data in two stages. During stage 1, both sides agreed the implant retrieved historic data, such as undeleted messages, from storage in a database on the EncroChat handsets.

Stage 2 was more controversial. Defence lawyers argued that evidence showed messages were captured live or in real time, during the course of transmission, while prosecutors argued the messages were obtained from storage in the phone handsets.

The judge concluded that references to “live” or “real-time” interception in evidence presented during the case referred to data captured and collected from storage before it was transmitted to the French authorities. Any “storage” before the implant collected the data would be “very brief”, but “very brief storage is still storage”.

Abuse of process

Defence lawyers argued that the defendants did not have the opportunity to present expert evidence on how the EncroChat evidence was obtained. They said the Crown had deliberately limited the disclosure of technical evidence, and delayed or concealed disclosure of evidence to prevent the defendants discovering how EncroChat data was intercepted.

The judge said there were elements of the Crown’s approach to disclosure that were less than optimal, and that “some criticism” of its conduct is not misplaced, but that there was “no misconduct”.

Between March 2022 and March 2023, defence lawyers asked the NCA to disclose technical information and infected EncroChat phones to assist an expert witness, Ross Anderson, professor of security engineering at Cambridge University, and later, Czeck company Invasys, to reverse-engineer the implant.

The process exposed “disclosure problems” and revealed a “sometimes sub-optimal approach by the Crown”, but the judge found that failures in disclosure were a consequence of the scale of the EncroChat cases in the UK and the early distribution of EncroChat data to disparate police forces.

Public interest immunity

Dean issued an order requiring the NCA and prosecutors to disclose two EncroChat phones and the technique used by the NCA to extract EncroChat APK files from the phone to defence experts to aid their understanding of how the phones worked, on 13 March 2020.

Prosecutors applied for Public Interest Immunity (PII) on 13 April, and on 17 May, the judge issued an order to prevent the disclosure of the APK technique and the infected handsets. The PII ruling also prevented the disclosure of new information that, according to prosecutors, “definitively establishes that the EncroChat material was … intercepted, at a time when it was stored on the relevant EncroChat handsets”.

Dean wrote in his ruling on 18 March: “Although I agree that there is always something unsatisfactory about any trial process in which relevant evidence cannot be deployed, unsatisfactory is not unfair.”

Simon Csoka KC, defending, had told the court the NCA and CPS had championed an at-best obstructive and at-worst dishonest approach to disclosure. The judge acknowledged that Csoka did not make these assertions gratuitously, but had pointed to evidence he described as a CPS strategy of dishonesty and obfuscation.

The judge found that the evidence was not consistent with a “malign and unlawful strategy”, but rather with a prosecution team discussing and sometimes struggling with the complexities of the EncroChat investigation and prosecution, and with the “sheer scale of their task”.

No oral evidence heard

Judge Dean rejected calls from defence lawyers to hear oral evidence during the trial from Emma Sweeting, the intelligence operations manager at the NCA, Luke Shrimpton, a former NCA senior technical expert, and Jeremy Decou, an officer at the French Gendarmerie.

The judge found that Emma Sweeting and Jeremy Decou were largely reporting things they had been told by others in written evidence about the French hacking operation, but rejected claims by defence lawyers that they amounted to “multiple hearsay” and should not be admitted.

The judge also found that any technical evidence Shrimpton had given in previous cases was no longer helpful in determining the facts relevant to storage versus transmission, and decided not to consider it.

The judge also rejected defence arguments that a letter of request by CPS to the French asking for clarification of how the implant worked told the French what the CPS wanted to hear, and signposted the catastrophic consequences of giving an answer that did not support the Crown’s case that EncroChat messages had been taken from storage.

Defence lawyers also argued that the French reply deliberately answered a different question in order to avoid telling an outright lie. The judge said that the argument was “fanciful”.

Leading junior scorer at Liverpool FC

Jamie Cassidy had been a leading scorer for Liverpool Football Club’s under-16s, and was described as a prodigy before his career was cut short with injuries.  

The court heard that Jamie Cassidy had been drawn into a conspiracy to import large quantities of drugs by his brother, Jonathan Cassidy.

The three men used anonymous handles on EncroChat. Jonathan Cassidy used “whiskywasp”, Amed used “dottetdaw” and Cassidy used “nucleardog”.

The court heard that Jonathan Cassidy had joked that he shared the same birthday as El Chapo, a drugs kingpin featured in an episode of Narcos.

Nasar Ahmed admitted acting as a money transfer agent for deals arranged by Jonathan Cassidy to import cocaine to the UK from the Netherlands.

The court heard that in April 2020, Ahmed switched from an EncroChat phone to another encrypted phone, Sky ECC, amid concerns EncroChat may have been compromised. He was arrested at his home on 15 June 2020, two days after the administrators of EncroChat put out a warning that the network had been infiltrated and was no longer secure.

Jonathan Cassidy flew to Dubai after learning about Ahmed’s arrest, where he considered buying a villa with a budget of £2.3m, which he intended to furnish with a £22,000 bed. He was arrested at Manchester Airport when he returned to England in October 2020.

Detectives estimated that Jonathan Cassidy and Nasar Ahmed were involved in importing close to £26m of drugs to the UK.

Sentencing, Dean said that although EncroChat phones were used by organised crime groups, there were relatively loose ties between Ahmed and Jonathan Cassidy. “It would not be accurate to say that Jonathon Cassidy and Nasar Ahmed were part of an organised crime group,” he added. “They were operating independently, but to their joint mutual benefit.”

The judge said Jamie Cassidy had a more limited involvement in the drug conspiracy. The court heard that he worked as a prison listener with the Samaritans.  

Tenacious legal challenge

Wayne Johns, the NCA’s Operation Venetic senior investigating officer, said: “The Cassidy brothers and Ahmed pleaded guilty in this case after years of tenaciously challenging the legality of the case against them. The NCA and Crown Prosecution Service worked with GMP to robustly defend the challenge, and we now see the trio where they belong.”

Detective Constable Marc Walby from the Greater Manchester Police Serious Organised Crime Group said the three men were from the upper echelons of organised criminals that operate in Greater Manchester.

“Jonathan Cassidy and his colleagues got far too comfortable with their encrypted phones and began bragging about their personal lives, but this just confirmed what we already knew about them,” he said. “Ironically, it was this bravado and these messages which have landed them in jail for a long time.

“This has been a long-running and complex case, and I would like to thank the NCA and CPS for their pursuit in defending the legal challenges associated with this case. Without, these convictions may not have been possible.”

Jonathan Cassidy of Whitewood Park, Liverpool, was jailed for 21 years and nine months for conspiracy to import cocaine, conspiracy to supply cocaine, and conspiracy to conceal, transfer and disguise criminal proceeds. Nasar Ahmed of Moreton Drive, Bury, was jailed for 21 years and nine months for conspiracy to import cocaine, conspiracy to supply cocaine, and conspiracy to conceal, transfer and disguise criminal proceeds. Jamie Cassidy of Knowsley Lane, Knowsley, was jailed for 13 years and three months for conspiracy to supply cocaine, and conspiracy to conceal, transfer and disguise criminal proceeds.

A manhunt is underway for another suspect, Joshua Avis, who absconded during pre-trial hearings. 

>>> Read full article>>>
Copyright for syndicated content belongs to the linked Source : Computer Weekly – https://www.computerweekly.com/news/366575017/Court-finds-EncroChat-hacked-messages-admissible-as-former-footballer-is-jailed

Tags: courtfindstechnology
Previous Post

Nationwide building society falls victim to IT outage

Next Post

Cryptocurrency Market Outlook: Cautious Optimism Amidst Consolidation

Sports on TV: Friday, May 23, 2025 – Miami Herald

Don’t Miss the Exciting Sports Lineup This Friday, May 23, 2025!

May 23, 2025
Chimpanzees use medicinal leaves to perform first aid – Frontiers

Chimpanzees use medicinal leaves to perform first aid – Frontiers

May 23, 2025
Three Students Earn National Science Foundation Graduate Research Fellowships – UConn Today

UConn Students Shine as National Science Foundation Graduate Research Fellowship Recipients!

May 23, 2025
Modern Ag Alliance Urges Science-Based Agricultural Policy in Response to MAHA Commission Report Questioning Crop Protection Tools – Morningstar

Modern Ag Alliance Calls for Science-Driven Agricultural Policies Following MAHA Commission’s Crop Protection Report

May 23, 2025
Summer must-haves from lifestyle contributor Limor Suss – WWLP

Essential Summer Must-Haves You Can’t Live Without!

May 23, 2025
New World drags Hong Kong banks into a loan tango – Reuters

New World Sparks a Loan Tango for Hong Kong Banks

May 23, 2025
Droughts are major threat to Eurozone economy, warns ECB – Financial Times

ECB Sounds Alarm: Droughts Pose Significant Risk to Eurozone Economy

May 23, 2025
Embracer intends to spin off Coffee Stain Group by the end of 2025, with remaining business rebranded as Fellowship Entertainment – GamesIndustry.biz

Embracer intends to spin off Coffee Stain Group by the end of 2025, with remaining business rebranded as Fellowship Entertainment – GamesIndustry.biz

May 23, 2025
Read the Full ‘Make America Healthy Again’ Report – The New York Times

Discover the Insights of the ‘Make America Healthy Again’ Report!

May 23, 2025
‘OPB Politics Now’: An inside look at how OPB covers the Oregon Capitol – Oregon Public Broadcasting – OPB

Behind the Scenes: Discover How OPB Captures the Heart of Oregon Politics

May 23, 2025

Categories

Archives

May 2025
MTWTFSS
 1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031 
« Apr    
Earth-News.info

The Earth News is an independent English-language daily published Website from all around the World News

Browse by Category

  • Business (20,132)
  • Ecology (631)
  • Economy (644)
  • Entertainment (21,557)
  • General (15,227)
  • Health (9,685)
  • Lifestyle (649)
  • News (22,149)
  • People (647)
  • Politics (652)
  • Science (15,868)
  • Sports (21,154)
  • Technology (15,633)
  • World (634)

Recent News

Sports on TV: Friday, May 23, 2025 – Miami Herald

Don’t Miss the Exciting Sports Lineup This Friday, May 23, 2025!

May 23, 2025
Chimpanzees use medicinal leaves to perform first aid – Frontiers

Chimpanzees use medicinal leaves to perform first aid – Frontiers

May 23, 2025
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact

© 2023 earth-news.info

No Result
View All Result

© 2023 earth-news.info

No Result
View All Result

© 2023 earth-news.info

Go to mobile version