Introduction
Rules of Engagement
Test Ride 1: from Kings Beach to Truckee (11 miles)
Test Ride 2: I-80 from Truckee to Blue Canyon (36 miles)
Test Ride 3: from West-Valley College to I-85 Entrance (1 mile)
Conclusion
In the past months, Tesla has been offering a free, one-month trial of their full
self-driving (FSD) system to all current owners. It looks like they are rolling this
out in stages, because I only got mine only a few days ago.
I’ve had a Model Y for more than 3 years now, well before Elon revealed himself as the
kind of person he really is, and I’ve been happy with it. The odometer is now well
above 50,000 miles, a significant part of those were spent on I-80 while driving between the
SF South Bay and the Lake Tahoe area.
For long distance interstate driving, autopilot (in other words: lane centering and
adaptive cruise control) has been amazing. I use it all the time, and have little to
complain about. Early on, I had one case where the autopilot started slowing down
for no good reason, but since I distrust these kind of systems and since phantom braking
has been reported quite a bit in the press, I try to keep attention to what the car is doing
at all times. I immediately pressed the accelerator, and that was that.
I don’t know how prevalent phantom breaking really is. One time is still too many, and
disconcerting. It doesn’t help that you can’t anticipate it, there must by a bunch of different
factors to trigger it: version of the car, weather, light conditions etc. All I can say, after
so many miles, is that autopilot has been amazing for me.
When I buy my next car, my requirements will be simple: I want an EV, an extensive charger
network along I-80, and an autosteer that’s at least as good as what I have today. Let’s hope
there’ll be decent Tesla alternatives by then.
But let’s get to FSD.
During his last financial conference call, Musk claimed that he wants to focus more on robo-taxis.
With no driver in the car at all, such a system better be pretty much flawless. But with the
YouTube videos that are out there, often posted by Tesla fans, that show the system making
ridiculous errors, I highly doubt that the system is close to ready. I would never pay for FSD,
not only do I not trust it, I also don’t really see the point, but with with a free trial,
I couldn’t resist checking it out.
Here are my impressions.
During 3 short tests, I watched FSD the way a helicopter parent watches a toddler who’s first
exploring the world: allow it do what it wants to do, but intervene the moment you feel things
are not going the way you like it.
It’s common on social media to see comments like this: “if the driver had waited a bit more,
FSD would still have corrected itself.” I’m having none of that. The moment I’m sensing it’s on
its way to do something, anything, wrong, I intervene.
While it’s possible that benign cases are dinged as interventions, I don’t think any what I
describe below can be considered as such. They were real mistakes that should never have happened.
I first switched on FSD for an 11 mile drive
from a mountain biking trailhead in Kings Beach to the I-80 entrance in Truckee, with a stop
at a gas station to get some snacks.
Click to open in Google Maps
This is not a complicated tasks. Other than the gas stop, it’s just driving straight along state
route 267 with a 3 traffic lights. What could possibly go wrong? Well, FSD managed to make 2 mistakes.
Mistake 1: select the wrong exit lane
During the first mistake, instead of turning right at the gas station, it made the decision to prepare
to exit one street early, switched on its indicator, and started moving to the right exit lane. Note
that there is no way to get to the gas station through that first exit.
If I hadn’t immediately interrupted that maneuver (see Rules of Engagement), I assume it would
have corrected itself eventually and gone back onto the main lane. But if I had been the driver behind,
I’d have questioned the antics of the driver in front of me.
FSD managed to screw up its very first maneuver. Not a good look.
Mistake 2: selecting the right turn lane when going straight
The second mistake happened less than a mile later.
At the intersection with Old Brockway Rd, the car was supposed to continue straight. There are 3
lanes at the traffic light: left, middle, and right, and only the middle lane can be used
to go straight.
For whatever reason, FSD initiated a move to go to the right lane. Another case where I’m sure it
would have corrected itself eventually, but it’s clear that the system had no clue about the
traffic situation in front of it.
While both cases are not life-or-death situations, it’s truly impressive that FSD managed to make 2
easily avoided mistakes before my first 10 miles of using it!
For the second test, my wife reluctantly gave me permission to try out FSD for interstate driving,
which should be its best case scenario.
Click to open in Google Maps
It’s a bit disconcerting to see the car make a decision to change lanes to pass someone, but I guess
that’s something you’ll get used to.
But what was baffling was the way in which it behaved worse than autopilot.
There were two nearly identical cases, where the 2-lane road was dead straight, with excellent paint marks,
and with cars right of me, yet FSD made nervous left-right oscillation-like corrections that I have never
experienced before in autopilot mode. It was not a case of FSD wanting to change lanes, no right indicator
was ever switched on.
The first time, my wife questioned what was going on. The second time, on a section just past
the Whitmore Caltrans station near Alta, she ordered me to switch off FSD. In the past 3 years, she
never once asked me to switch off autopilot.
One would think that autopilot and FSD have the same core lane tracking algorithms, but one way or the other
the experience was radically different. I switched back to autopilot. The remaining 3 hours were uneventful.
The final test happened yesterday, while driving back from the
Silicon Valley Electronics Flea Market
back home.
These are always held on a Sunday, start very early at 6am, and I’m usually out before 9am, so there’s
almost nobody on the road.
Click to open in Google Maps
FSD managed to turn right out of the parking lot just fine and get past the first traffic light.
The second traffic light has a don’t-turn-on-red sign. The light was red, the Tesla came to a full stop,
and then pressed on the gas to move on while the light was still red. (According to my colleague, police
often lay in wait at this location to catch violators.)
By now I fully expected it to make that mistake, so I was ready to press the brake.
The way it currently behaves, FSD is a system that can’t be trusted to make the right decisions. It makes
the most basic mistakes and it makes many of them.
Without FSD, you pay attention to the road and everything else is within your control. With FSD, you still
need to pay attention but now there’s the additional cognitive load to monitor an unpredictable system over
which you don’t have direct control. Forget about just being focused, you need to be hyper-focused, and you
need to pay $99 per month or a one time fee of $12,000 for the privilege. With the limited functionality of autopilot,
you hit the sweet spot: adaptive cruise control and lane centering work reliably, and you don’t need to
worry about any other mischief.
Maybe one day I’ll be able to drive to Lake Tahoe by typing in the address, sit back, take a nap,
or play on my phone. Until then, it’s just a fancy technology demo with little practical value.
>>> Read full article>>>
Copyright for syndicated content belongs to the linked Source : Hacker News – https://tomverbeure.github.io/2024/05/20/Tesla-FSD-First-and-Last-Impressions.html